Picked Last MLB Playoff Preview: A’s vs Tigers

No more wildcards. With MLB Playoffs starting, Picked Last picks ’em forreal this time:

Detroit Tigers LogoTigers

Why you should love them: They’ve got a lot of really fun personalities who are also really really really good at baseball. From Miguel Cabrera’s historically elite past two seasons, where he basically replicated his 2012 Triple Crown numbers, to the once-a-vegan Prince Fielder who rumbles across the basepaths and reminds one of an elite Jon Kruk’s “Lady, I ain’t an athlete, I’m a baseball player”, to the dominating Max Scherzer coupled with Verlander being Verlander, to a host of others like Victor Martinez etc etc etc. They lost their starting shortstop to PED suspension and didn’t even skip a beat. This team is stacked, loaded, and ready to go deep. Also, can anyone really root against the city of Detroit? Or Torii Hunter making it to his first World Series?

Why you shouldn’t: They’re Goliath, talent-wise. Anyone facing them will be looking for that Achille’s Heel, and should be applauded if they can find it, between their dominate hitting and dominant pitching.

oakland a's
Why you should love them: Billy Beane is a survivor, isn’t he? After a few years in purgatory as the rest of the Majors caught up to his embrace of sabermetrics, the A’s GM has bounced back and actually won 3 more games than the talent-rich Tigers this year in a much tougher division (AL West vs. AL Central). For the second year, they passed the Rangers in the last weeks of September to grab hold of the AL West. They’ve got 40 years young Bartolo Colon taking the mound to open the series. The A’s, despite having the 4th lowest payroll in the Big Leagues, are in this thing. They don’t have many gang-busters, but they play as a team. With no All-Stars this year, they continue to compete with little resources. Also, I like the A’s because as the Philadelphia A’s, they brought 5 World Series titles to Philly during Connie Mack’s 50 year reign over the Philadelphia sports landscape.

Why you shouldn’t: The A’s have never done well in the playoffs under Billy Beane, which is the weakness of a pure sabermetrics approach. It devalues the manager, whose job it is to win day-to-day games, which, in the playoffs, that’s what it’s all about. The Colliseum is a shitty place to watch a game.-James
Addendum: We can disagree on the analytical approach (most of the playoffs bear it out in my favor though I believe), but what’s probably going to lead Detroit to win is Fielder/Cabrera and a pitching staff top 3 in ERA and FIP in the AL, not an old white dude vs. another old white dude,
Look, I would love for the A’s to win this thing. I’d be stoked. But we’re giving a prediction of what we think is most likely to happen. Reducing homerism, we asked a Philly friend to write this up.
I’m calling Tigers in 4, maybe 5 I’d prefer to be proven wrong, as I’ve got ALCS tickets.-Harjit
Picked Last Prediction: Tigers in 3

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s